Monday, November 5, 2012

M. Butterfly Poses a Question

An interesting aspect of M.Butterfly comes up in the first four pages: How could a man have a relationship for twenty years and not realize it was with another man?  As discussed in class, this brings up issues of the importance of gender in relationships and society.  The scene in which two men and a woman sort of joke about Gallimard's circumstance, in a way, reflects Cohen's piece about Oscar Wilde's trial posing as a sodomite.  Cohen's article focuses on how easily the public can be troubled by simply posing as something that one is not, and in this cause, with sexuality, it was particularly disturbing.  This mainly is due to the realization that gender and sexuality is a performance that can be easily used to reinforce or deny typical masculinity or femininity.  The plot of M. Butterfly relies on a man posing as a woman and perusing a relationship with another man.  The scene mentioned above, where random members of society are discussing the outrageous aspects of the situation, reflects the realizations met in Cohen's piece.  This is another example in which gender can be a performance and society finds this troubling due to how easily it can be changed with simple changes in dress or acts.  It will be interesting to see how the topic of gender and what constitutes male and female characteristics are discussed further in the play.

2 comments:

Unknown said...

I find it interesting that you connect this to Cohen's theories about Wilde. This is completely true that there is no right or wrong in either situation and there are always going to be people talking and gossiping about it. I find the gender issue interesting as well. Song is completely posing just as Wilde did and yet it takes her twenty years to be found out. Where we are in the novel also shows that she doesn't want to be exploited or found out whereas Wilde was desperate for attention and exploited his experiences.

Unknown said...

I never thought of relating Oscar Wilde's trial of 'posing as a sodomite' to the societal confusion of Gallimard and Song's relationship. It is clear that through their mockery and humor, the men in the beginning of M Butterfly feel very threatened and with the relationship and concerned that the confusion happened so easily. This also brings up the question we began asking in class of "does the gender really matter?" Why is it so disturbing to society what gender you 'pose' as. I think the author of M Butterfly is suggesting that society should refrain from prosecuting those that make them feel uncomfortable or seem threatening to the social norm.

Post a Comment

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.